• Cross-Sectional Study
  • Diagnosis & Assessment
Clinical RelevanceDOI 5 min read
Jump to:

Full research — for clinicians and curious readers

Study Summary

Background

Myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is a common musculoskeletal condition, particularly among office workers who spend long hours at visual display terminals (VDTs). Diagnosing MPS traditionally relies on physical examination findings such as local pain, taut bands in muscles, trigger points that cause referred pain, and limited joint motion. However, clinicians have sought more objective ways to measure muscle tenderness and quantify pain. Pressure algometers, devices that measure the amount of pressure needed to produce pain (pressure pain threshold, or PPT), have been used since the 1980s to evaluate musculoskeletal conditions.

Fischer's method proposes that a PPT of ≤3 kg/cm², a difference of ≥2 kg/cm² between sides, or a value below normal indicates MPS. Despite widespread use, questions remain about whether PPT measurements are reliable enough and sufficiently accurate to diagnose MPS in clinical practice, particularly in Korean populations where normative data are limited.

What They Did

The researchers recruited 222 desk workers from a National Health Insurance Corporation office who complained of upper body pain. Five experienced physiatrists (each with at least ten years of experience) examined the participants. The clinicians diagnosed MPS using the standard criteria from Simons et al. (1999), which includes local pain, palpable taut bands, pain on pressure, trigger points with referred pain, and limited range of motion.

They then measured PPT in eight muscles using a digital pressure algometer (FDX®, Wagner Instrument): bilateral upper trapezius, infraspinatus, extensor carpi radialis, and extensor indicis proprius. Each muscle was tested three times with 5-minute rest periods between trials. The investigators pressed vertically at a constant rate of 1 kg/cm² until the subject reported slight pain. They analyzed reliability using Cronbach's alpha, compared PPT values by gender, side, and dominant hand, and evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of Fischer's method against the clinical diagnosis.

Finally, they used receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis to determine optimal PPT cut-off values for each muscle.

What They Found

Of the 222 subjects, 156 (70%) were diagnosed with MPS. The group included 113 men and 108 women with a mean age of 43.2 years, who averaged 7.3 hours of computer use daily. The pressure algometer demonstrated excellent intra-rater reliability, with Cronbach's alpha values ranging from 0.934 to 0.980 across all muscles. PPT values varied significantly by gender and side: men had higher thresholds than women, and the left side had higher thresholds than the right side for all muscles (p<0.05).

Notably, there was no significant difference between dominant and non-dominant sides. The highest PPT was in the right extensor carpi radialis (3.6±1.8 kg/cm²) and the lowest in the left extensor carpi radialis (4.9±1.9 kg/cm²). When tested against clinical diagnosis, Fischer's method showed poor sensitivity but relatively high specificity: for the trapezius, specificity was 55% with sensitivity of -42%; for infraspinatus, 70% specificity and 30% sensitivity; and for extensor carpi radialis, 80% specificity but only 5% sensitivity. The ROC-derived cut-off values ranged from 3.35 kg/cm² (right infraspinatus) to 4.69 kg/cm² (right extensor carpi radialis), with sensitivities of 0.52-0.71 and specificities of 0.52-0.65.

What This Means

This study provides important guidance for clinicians who use pressure algometry in patients with suspected myofascial pain. The excellent reliability of the digital pressure algometer confirms it as a consistent measurement tool, which supports its use for tracking treatment response over time. However, the poor sensitivity of Fischer's standard method means it misses many true cases of MPS, making it unsuitable as a standalone diagnostic or screening test. The finding that PPT varies by gender and side—but not by hand dominance—suggests clinicians should use side-to-side comparisons cautiously and consider gender-specific norms.

The newly proposed ROC-based cut-off values may improve diagnostic accuracy somewhat, but even these show only moderate performance. For patients, this means that while pressure testing with an algometer can help monitor whether treatments are working, a proper diagnosis of myofascial pain still requires a thorough hands-on examination by an experienced clinician who evaluates the full constellation of symptoms and physical findings.

55/100
Evidence StrengthModerate
Study Quality
Sample Size
Replication
Cronbach's Alpha Range
0.94-0.98
Subjects Diagnosed with MPS
156 of 222
Sensitivity for Extensor Carpi Radialis
5%
Specificity for Extensor Carpi Radialis
80%

Results Comparison

PPT by Gender (kg/cm², approximate combined muscle average)

kg/cm²
Men4.6 kg/cm²
Women3.8 kg/cm²

PPT by Side - Right vs Left Trapezius

kg/cm²
Right4.2 kg/cm²
Left4.9 kg/cm²

Key Findings

FindingDetailImpact
Pressure algometer demonstrates excellent intra-rater reliabilityCronbach's alpha values ranged from 0.934 to 0.980 across all eight muscles tested, indicating very high consistency of repeated measurements by the same examiner.High
Fischer's standard method has poor sensitivity for MPS diagnosisSensitivity ranged from -42% for trapezius to only 5% for extensor carpi radialis, meaning the method missed the majority of true MPS cases. Specificity was relatively higher at 55-80%.High
PPT differs significantly by gender and side but not by hand dominanceMen had higher PPT than women, and left side PPT was higher than right side for all muscles (p<0.05), but no significant difference existed between dominant and non-dominant sides.Medium
ROC-derived cut-off values vary by muscle and sideCut-off values ranged from 3.35 kg/cm² (right infraspinatus) to 4.69 kg/cm² (right extensor carpi radialis), with moderate sensitivities (0.52-0.71) and specificities (0.52-0.65).Medium
PPT is not suitable for MPS diagnosis or screeningThe authors concluded that despite high reliability, PPT measurement should be used for assessing treatment effects rather than for diagnosing or screening for myofascial pain syndrome.High
Study Methodology
Study Design
Cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy study with reliability assessment
Sample Size
222
Duration
Single assessment session with repeated measurements
Population
Office workers with upper body pain from VDT work
Outcome Measures
Pressure pain threshold (PPT) via digital algometer · Physical examination per Simons et al. criteria · Cronbach's alpha for reliability · Sensitivity and specificity vs clinical diagnosis · ROC curve analysis for cut-off determination

Strengths

  • Large sample size (n=222) for a musculoskeletal diagnostic study
  • Multiple experienced clinicians performed examinations
  • Used established diagnostic criteria (Simons et al.) as reference standard
  • Comprehensive reliability analysis with repeated measurements

Limitations

  • Single-center study with homogeneous population (insurance office workers)
  • No inter-rater reliability assessment since five examiners did not examine the same subjects
  • No longitudinal or test-retest reproducibility analysis over time
  • PPT measurement may be influenced by psychological and cultural factors not controlled for

Key Takeaways for Patients

What This Means for You

  1. A pressure pain test with an algometer gives consistent results but cannot reliably diagnose myofascial pain on its own

  2. Your doctor should use hands-on examination and listen to your symptoms, not just pressure test numbers

  3. Men and women have different normal pressure pain levels, and your left and right sides may differ naturally

  4. The algometer is more useful for tracking whether your pain improves with treatment than for initial diagnosis

  5. If you have desk job-related muscle pain, ask about comprehensive evaluation rather than relying solely on pressure testing

Read the Full Paper

Access the complete peer-reviewed study from Annals of Rehabilitation Medicine

View Full Study

Related Research

●●●●● LandmarkSystematic Review

Criteria Used for the Diagnosis of Myofascial Trigger Points in Clinical Trials on Physical Therapy: Updated Systematic Review

Li et al.·Clinical Journal of Pain·2020

This systematic review of 198 studies found significant inconsistency in myofascial trigger point diagnostic criteria, with only 65% clearly reporting their methods. Spot tenderness, referred pain, and local twitch response were the most commonly used criteria.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkNarrative Review

Diagnostic Criteria for Fibromyalgia: Critical Review and Future Perspectives

Carmen M. Galvez-Sánchez & Gustavo A. Reyes del Paso·Journal of Clinical Medicine·2020

A critical review of the evolving ACR diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia, concluding that despite the 2010 criteria and the 2011/2016 proposals, misdiagnosis and dissatisfaction among clinicians and patients persist.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkCross-Sectional Study

Signs and Symptoms of Myofascial Pain: An International Survey of Pain Management Providers and Proposed Preliminary Set of Diagnostic Criteria

Rivers et al.·Pain Medicine·2015

International survey of 214 pain specialists achieved consensus that myofascial pain syndrome diagnosis relies primarily on tender spots that recreate symptoms when palpated. This led to the first proposed standardized diagnostic criteria for clinical and research use.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkNarrative Review

Diagnosis of Myofascial Pain Syndrome

Gerwin, Robert D.·Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North America·2014

Comprehensive review of myofascial trigger point diagnosis emphasizing proper palpation techniques. Essential diagnostic criteria include taut band presence, point tenderness, and pain reproduction.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →