Cross-Sectional StudyDiagnosis & AssessmentClinical RelevanceDOI
4 min read
Jump to:

Patient-friendly summary

If you read nothing else

This study looks at how the size and stiffness of muscle knots in your lower back, called MTrPs, can help diagnose back pain using ultrasound images.

Bottom line

This study shows that ultrasound can help diagnose back pain by measuring the stiffness of muscle knots, which might be useful for your doctor.

Preliminary evidence

Study participants

n=25

adults diagnosed with non-specific low back pain

Published

2024
2 years ago
Current

Evidence hierarchy

Meta-analysis
Systematic Review
RCT
Cohort
Case-Control ◀ this study
Case Report
Expert Opinion

You're not alone

“It's common to have muscle pain in your lower back, and understanding these muscle knots can help in finding the right treatment for you.”

Full research — for clinicians and curious readers

Study Summary

Background

Myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is a regional pain disorder characterized by trigger points (MTrPs) in muscle tissue, but its role in low back pain remains poorly understood. While studies suggest 63.5-90% of low back pain patients may have MPS, there's limited research characterizing patients with MPS specifically in the lower back region. This lack of understanding hampers proper diagnosis and treatment of a potentially widespread condition.

What They Did

Researchers conducted a cross-sectional study of 25 participants with chronic low back pain who had palpable trigger points confirmed by ultrasound examination. An osteopathic physician examined participants using physical palpation to identify trigger points, which were then verified using ultrasound to confirm hypo-echogenicity. Participants were categorized into four groups based on trigger point characteristics: Group 1 (active MTrPs with spontaneous pain and twitching), Group 2 (latent MTrPs with twitching but no spontaneous pain), Group 3 (atypical MTrPs with spontaneous pain but no twitching), and Group 4 (atypical MTrPs with neither spontaneous pain nor twitching). Researchers measured pain pressure threshold, physical function tests, quality of life questionnaires, and self-reported pain levels.

What They Found

All 25 participants had multiple trigger points (average 4.36 trigger points per person), with 100% showing ultrasound confirmation of trigger point abnormalities. Participants with spontaneous pain (Groups 1 and 3) had significantly more trigger points (4.73 vs 3.80), higher current pain levels (3.80 vs 1.70), and worse pain in the past 24 hours (6.27 vs 3.10) compared to those without spontaneous pain. Interestingly, Group 3 (spontaneous pain without twitching) showed the worst physical function, highest pain levels, and most trigger points. The presence of spontaneous pain was more important for predicting poor physical function than the classic twitching response.

Female participants had longer pain duration and higher catastrophizing scores, while Black participants showed worse physical function and higher disability scores.

What This Means

This study challenges traditional trigger point definitions by showing that spontaneous pain may be more clinically important than the classic twitching response for identifying problematic trigger points. The finding that all participants had multiple trigger points suggests MPS may be more common in low back pain than previously recognized. Clinicians should look for multiple trigger points in low back pain patients and focus on spontaneous pain rather than just twitching responses when assessing trigger points. The study also highlights the importance of considering sex and ethnicity in MPS assessment and treatment planning.

45/100
Evidence StrengthModerate
Study Quality
Sample Size
Replication
100%
Had Ultrasound-Confirmed Trigger Points
4.36
Average Trigger Points per Patient
p=0.001
Pain Difference Between Groups
Enrolled

25

Randomized
n=13

Active MTrP

Spontaneous pain + twitching response

n=5

Latent MTrP

Twitching response, no spontaneous pain

n=2

Atypical MTrP (pain)

Spontaneous pain, no twitching

n=5

Atypical MTrP (no pain)

No spontaneous pain, no twitching

Results Comparison

Current Pain (0-10 scale)

points
Spontaneous Pain Groups3.8 points
No Spontaneous Pain Groups1.7 points

Number of Trigger Points

count
Spontaneous Pain Groups4.73 count
No Spontaneous Pain Groups3.8 count

Key Findings

All participants had ultrasound-confirmed trigger pointsHigh

100% of chronic low back pain patients showed hypo-echogenicity on ultrasound examination

Spontaneous pain more predictive than twitching responseHigh

Groups with spontaneous pain had significantly worse physical function and higher pain levels regardless of twitching

Multiple trigger points are the normMedium

Average of 4.36 trigger points per patient, with those having spontaneous pain showing more trigger points

Atypical trigger points may be clinically relevantMedium

Group 3 (spontaneous pain without twitching) showed worst outcomes, challenging traditional definitions

Sex and ethnicity influence MPS presentationMedium

Females had longer pain duration and higher catastrophizing; Black participants showed worse function

Study Methodology
Study Design
Cross-sectional observational study
Sample Size
25
Duration
Single assessment session
Population
Adults with chronic low back pain and palpable trigger points
Outcome Measures
Physical palpation · Ultrasound verification · Pain pressure threshold · Physical function tests · Quality of life questionnaires

Strengths

  • Used ultrasound verification to confirm trigger point presence
  • Comprehensive assessment with multiple validated questionnaires
  • Novel categorization approach including atypical trigger points
  • Examined interaction effects between pain and twitching responses

Limitations

  • Very small sample size (N=25) limits generalizability
  • Cross-sectional design prevents causal inferences
  • Highly educated sample may not represent general population
  • Single examiner for trigger point identification

Key Takeaways for Patients

What This Means for You

  1. 01If you have chronic low back pain, you likely have multiple trigger points that can be confirmed with ultrasound imaging
  2. 02Ongoing spontaneous pain may be more important than muscle twitches when identifying problematic trigger points
  3. 03Your sex and ethnicity may influence how trigger points affect you - women tend to have longer pain duration while some ethnic groups may experience worse physical function
  4. 04Traditional trigger point definitions may need updating to include atypical presentations that still cause significant symptoms
  5. 05Multiple trigger points are normal in low back pain, not just single isolated problem areas

Read the Full Paper

Access the complete peer-reviewed study from Scientific Reports

View Full Study

Related Research

●●●●● LandmarkSystematic Review

Criteria Used for the Diagnosis of Myofascial Trigger Points in Clinical Trials on Physical Therapy: Updated Systematic Review

Li et al.·Clinical Journal of Pain·2020

This systematic review of 198 studies found significant inconsistency in myofascial trigger point diagnostic criteria, with only 65% clearly reporting their methods. Spot tenderness, referred pain, and local twitch response were the most commonly used criteria.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkNarrative Review

Diagnostic Criteria for Fibromyalgia: Critical Review and Future Perspectives

Carmen M. Galvez-Sánchez & Gustavo A. Reyes del Paso·Journal of Clinical Medicine·2020

A critical review of the evolving ACR diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia, concluding that despite the 2010 criteria and the 2011/2016 proposals, misdiagnosis and dissatisfaction among clinicians and patients persist.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkCross-Sectional Study

Signs and Symptoms of Myofascial Pain: An International Survey of Pain Management Providers and Proposed Preliminary Set of Diagnostic Criteria

Rivers et al.·Pain Medicine·2015

International survey of 214 pain specialists achieved consensus that myofascial pain syndrome diagnosis relies primarily on tender spots that recreate symptoms when palpated. This led to the first proposed standardized diagnostic criteria for clinical and research use.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →
●●●●● LandmarkNarrative Review

Diagnosis of Myofascial Pain Syndrome

Gerwin, Robert D.·Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North America·2014

Comprehensive review of myofascial trigger point diagnosis emphasizing proper palpation techniques. Essential diagnostic criteria include taut band presence, point tenderness, and pain reproduction.

Diagnosis & AssessmentRead →